This feels fake. I could be wrong and hope I am.
No manager competent enough to write that well is going to put anything like that down in writing. Totally fake.
I worked for an IT manager who fired me after I pointed out that he was scammed for buying a 6 pack 1TB flash drives from Amazon for $40.
He wrote an email saying I was a jerk for delegitimizing his authority which I took to HR and was fired the next day “for not being a good culture fit” and was paid to be under a nondisclosure for half a year.
I am like Mulder, I believe the morons are out there.
Good reminder not to trust HR.
There ARE a lot of incompetent managers out there though …
It actually sounds like ChatGPT, so…
It’s an AI written justification.
Could still be fake, but there are absolutely people that are this stupid and use chatgpt.
It doesn’t read like it’s generated, but I’m not really that savvy on these things
There’s people at Amazon that thought an AI only phone is a good idea
That was one of my first thoughts too, but I’m not sure that’s a sign of it being fake.
The whole thing is curious but I’d need more detail to make a confident statement.
Yep. This would never ever be an email. It’ll be a in-person meeting.
Why? It leaves a paper trial, and it’s written too “smart”.
I have broken some HR policies before - real stupid ones (like using the bathroom too much or something ridiculous) and had “the meeting”.
But when I ask them to give me a written version of the issues after the meeting, it’s always vague and points to line items in the handbook.
Find another job, get a start date, call out first day of new job, if you like new job quit old next morning. They don’t deserve any notice. Simple.
You could read between the lines and realize your attitude affects the team in a negative way.
that reply is all you need, time to start looking for something else
Just don’t work anymore and instead chat cheerfully with your coworkers. Its the same quality work. Bring the vibes xD
Can’t tell if the boss’ reply is AI text or just kool-aid drunk businessman.
absolutely written by AI. I can even guess the prompt
My vote is thinly disguised sexism.
Does that even count as a disguise? Either way was pretty dang sexist.
The world has enough “what’s your reaction?” content. No need to poll the internet, just make a decision and move on with your life.
but how else am I going to make thousands of people incessantly angry at a strawman if I don’t make them think I haven’t made it up?
THINK OF THE CLICKS! THE CLIIICKS! (to the tune of “She takes premium, dude”)
But it’s scary!
This is like saying the world has enough stories, so new stories don’t have a place anymore.
Hard disagree.
Should take your own advice sometimes? The world has enough comments.
I, however, am all for documenting unfair treatment and putting it out in the open.
Insta-quit.
Agree on the quit, disagree on the insta.
Use the time to apply and interview for a new job. Once you’ve secured a new position, then you quit. Don’t hurt your own finances while you hurt your old company.
And it’s up to you how much notice you give. Worth considering whether to preserve the professional relationships, or torch that bridge.
Did everyone clap, too?
I just don’t believe a boss would commit to writing “your output is higher and better but I like Tad’s vibe better.”
Just begging for a visit from HR.
I’ve been a union rep for a good few years and honestly you wouldn’t believe the shit I’ve seen managers put in writing. “It is company policy to commit crimes here” levels of brazenly breaking the law, especially for stuff like disability discrimination. I can 100% believe this.
Tbh, “company policy” are magical words.
I assume if something illegal gets labeled as “Company Policy” (even though it isn’t), the company should immediately be held accountable regardless - so terrible managers don’t get to throw those two words around as a magic shield to protect themselves from employees being cognitively indisonant, unlike their perfect selves.
My bosses must be smarter than the most them because they refuse to ever put anything in writing.
Yeah, don’t believe this at all. Reads like some dream sequence someone had. Even the dumbest managers wouldn’t say something this stupid, they all know this is a trip right to HR.
Even the dumbest managers
You’re overestimating people.
When I was a manager, I refused to discuss another employee with their coworker. If you want a raise, tell me why you deserve a raise for what you do. And I was very careful to only put established company policy in writing, everything else was “let’s circle back to that in person when we’re both at the office.”
Consider yourself lucky then.
I have absolutely met managers this dumb. I had a manager quote me in an email reply, with what was quoted in the same email chain and included with the other replies, then forward it (still including all the replies!) claiming that he “rescued” me from a client incident because I didnt reply.
With the reply from me just two emails below.
Yes, there are absolute idiots in management who would 100% reply with this.
deleted by creator
Yeah, this feels like bullshit.
Is there anything actually illegal happening here?
I don’t believe this but you can absolutely fire someone for vibes.
Your attitude does affect team members. I’d happily fire a high out put team member for being an ass.
Sounds like an edge case
Nope. It’s a spectrum, but at some point “vibes” absolutely matter.
lol first time reading the opinions of morons?
I want some oponions. Regular onions aren’t doing it for me anymore.
These days there’s the possibly that a manager might just use an AI for response and not consider the implications if the tone looks professional at a glance, perhaps. There’s something that feels AI-ish about it anyway, but that could simply be the corporate “professional” writing style I suppose.
Work hard to get paid. Once you get paid, dial back that work folks. Dial it right back.
Do the minimum and go around the office socializing. If they complain, show them the email and tell them you’re working on the metrics they care about the most.
They are fucking, aren’t they?
Quit, without notice.
Quit
“What is it you’d say you do here?”
“I’m a vibes person! I deal with vibes!”
That sounds like a bit of a jump to conclusions















