Removed by mod
Democracy in China is very alive and well, contrary to Western public opinion.
Bullshit. Xi Jinpeng is President for life now. There is Chinese Democracy I suppose… in Taiwan. Which is under threat by Xi, just as there was democracy in Hong Kong before Xi snuffed that out.
Also the Nazis valued racial homogeneity, did that result in more democracy and freedoms?
You’re trying to make the facts fit a racist narrative. The reality is that cultural changes result from living in a free society. The culture doesn’t change in the same way in all places. The only way to have homogeneity is under an authoritative regime that forces people to all live the same lives. That isn’t freedom.
FFS there has been two languages in Canada for it’s entire existence. We’ve never been homogenous.
Removed by mod
So people in Taiwan and Hong Kong not Chinese now? You support the oppression of Chinese people, so if anyone is anti-Chinese, it’s you. I support the freedom of Chinese people.
And I never claimed that homogeneity would lead to democracy, but that perhaps democracy could only function in a homogeneous society.
Again… Canada has never been homogenous. “Homogeneity” means oppressing those that are different from the ruler. That’s always the hallmark of authoritarianism.
Can democracy survive a multicultural society, yes it can. Can it only exist in a homogeneous way, no. This is kind of the same question honestly.
A better question is, will powerful fascist elements use multicultural issues against democracy? The answer is yes.
Can a non-homogeneous democracy compete with a homogeneous? Do you think the US has competed successfully considering they have been non-homogeneous for awhile now.
I have never heard white elitism as the cause for the decline of democracy. I would say it has definitely created a two tired society where some white males get the benefits of other’s work disportionally.
Honestly your question(s) seem kind of race baiting in a mild way. Like you are looking for an answer you already have and just need confirmation.
I see your reliance on path and destination as a metaphor for the status quo and change misplaced. Democracies can and do change and the fact that not every group has the exact same goal does not prevent democracy.
It may make it more complex and slower because the groups must find common ground and develop shared goals. Or perhaps one group will simply dominate the other as we see in the US. Obviously there will be conflict if the groups have polar opposite demands.
I find your distinction between one party and no party just silly. China is not a democracy at all. The supreme power is invested in a autocrat. Of course, you could argue the US is very similar and depending how this next election plays out it may to become a no-party/one party government. I am sure some would argue it already is one party when it comes to serving the wealthy’s desires.
China is not driven by a singular goal as what the rural working class wants is completely different than the urban elites want. There is no way everyone in China can be a billionaire. This two-tired society is non-homogeneous by nature.
This new world is dominated by corporate interests. The wealthy are no longer bound by nations. I see us heading into an increasingly post-nation world for the wealthy with nations purely becoming a tool to control the populace and ignored by the wealthy.
I think every large nation, including the US could be broken up and probably be better off. This concentration of power under the guise of the state in order to control the populace at the benefit of the wealthy is a problem that is happening all over the world as income gaps continue to increase dramatically.
deleted by creator
…also there have always been great divisions in society. Look at Ireland Catholic vs. Protestant. Even in Ontario in the early days of this country each region was very different from the rest.
The main problem that we have now, is that ridings are too big, at 100,000 each. They should be no more than 30,000. That way people really get represented. This would also allow smaller region parties to establish themselves, like in the early days of Canada. It would also allow parties to be more fluid, coming into existing, transforming into another party. Without proper representation people are not represented.
First-Past-The-Post must go, it is not democratic. At the very minimum have runoff elections, even better to automate them with ranked ballots.
I think reforms could help with some things and certainly increasing the amount of representatives would reduce corruption by increasing the amount of people to be bribed. I don’t feel that popular voting will ever work though because it lends to corruption too easily
While Canada may not be as cooked as the US is, I can’t help the feeling that they have bought into Neo liberalism completely. This is pretty much incompatible with democracy in my opinion.
…neo-liberalism goes away when ridings get smaller. People focus on solving local issues. Currently with such big ridings, anything local and of importance doesn’t even get mentioned or solved politically.
It would be interesting to see if this reform would pay off as much as you think it would. I am in full support.
Removed by mod
You seem to be splitting hairs between multicultural population and a democratic multicultural population. How much representation does it take to get to the democratic part. Also, what about recent studies that highlight that US policies appear almost completely unaffected by the majority of the population.
In this respect the US would not qualify as a democratic multicultural population. The only time your vote matters is if you vote with the ruling class. In fact, the US government is actually structured to ignored the working class from the start with the Senate, Executive Branch, and Judiciary all designed to thwart the Congress.
Your point about Isreal and Palestinians is strange considering that Palestinians are not actually Israeli citizens. Not sure if you mean non-jewish Israeli citizens, if so I suppose it makes some sense.
There is no socialism destination for the US. If you lived here you would know socialism is a bad word. We even purged all of our leftists during McCarthyism. The destination is not capitalism either. It is has been fascism since before there was a word for it.
I don’t agree with you appraisal of China. Their destination is Neo authoritarianism like most of Asia right now. You could argue the US is heading this same way.
Removed by mod
Nice outing yourself. China’s so-called democracy would be stronger if it were a republic so that minorities, like the Uyghurs, would not get trampled in the process.
Find another place that makes you feel righteous and powerful and accepted. You can find friends volunteering in the community, for example.
And fuck the United States, so we’re clear where I’m coming from too.
Removed by mod
That you for clarification about your view of voting. I also think it is important to consider how effective the vote is. As I mentioned a study done about US policy indicates strongly that there is almost zero correlation between what people want and actual policy.
https://pnhp.org/news/gilens-and-page-average-citizens-have-little-impact-on-public-policy/
This has much wider implications than just US politics as this same tendency can be see in other countries as well. It also shows us that democracy is actually a window dressing for fascism (at least in the US).
I don’t mean to be dismissive, but if the best you can do to show socialism is accepted in the US is to cite Bernie and George then I would have to say that I respectfully disagree. They are the outliers and not even to the left at that. George is a straight up billionaire and Bernie hasn’t mentioned anything about giving workers ownership unless you count capilitistic driven ideas like ESOPs.
Having worked at the local, state, and federal level in the US I can definitely say that once it reaches the federal level the average citizen has next to no power to affect change.
I am not surprised you are in denial about China. I run into this with a lot of campists. I am not sure how you could look at Xi and not see an autocrat. Asia’s march into neo authoritarianism is well documented in Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, and China. Frankly, denying this shows a lack of candor that makes conversations convoluted at best.
Removed by mod
Thank you for the clarification. I do feel in some ways this is just a complex argument for racism and I have heard similar intricate arguments just like this to justify racism. This may not be your intention, but I think it is important for you to know this for the future.
What we find sociologically is that your “common sense” about homogeneous society is anything but.
“As diversity increases, people paradoxically perceive social groups as more similar,”
Essentially a non homogeneous society will increasingly accept other social groups as normal. This kind of puts your entire theory on its head, although I do see the point you are getting at.
Your denialism over China is both bizarre and telling. You are definitely acting as a campist as I had guessed already. I don’t have a dog in this fight so to speak, but I am also not here to be gaslit by an authoratarian apologist.
The reality is China is an just another oligarchy. They have probably the largest wealth gap of any nation in history and are pumping out more billionaires than the US the last three years. They are now the fourth largest supplier of arms to war torn nations and they have a long history of imperialistic endeavors.
China is great because of the US, not despite it. They have both conspired together to create wealth for an extreme minority. Trying to bill China as the lesser of evils is pretty silly even if I would generally agree just because the US in particular has caused more death and destruction than any nation in history.
“Every crisis is an opportunity”
– Every single slimy “liberal” politician who is really just a posh autoritarian with a toolbox of Identity Politics slogans.
It doesn’t help my hope for things that, every time Carney clearly represents the owner class over the working class, I see people in comment sections talking about they “don’t like it but you gotta get things done!”. No, this is bad and should not be excused, and why do we always have to have excuses and patience for centrist and right-wing bullshit, which has still yet to show any real functionality, but we won’t even try being progressive despite the innumerable examples of progressive policy working all over the world? Even Mamdani is making it work in the US and we act like Carney needs to allow unreviewed distruction of our environment to benefit O&G companies or the whole country will up and die in only a couple years’ time.
I’m so tired of this crap. I’m so tired of us willfully throwing away our rights and self-respect just to get leaders who will ignore us at every possible turn. I’m sick of people saying that the left will be like Soviet Russia while everything they describe as guaranteed with progressivism is literally happening, openly, in front of them under conservative governments(like our current one, too). Degrading our democracy almost feels like it’s still democratic because so much of the population seems perfectly happy to watch it happen.
Many jobs SHOULD be public sector jobs. Like water utilities, garbage collection, electrical utilities, teaching, college teacher.
These public sector jobs should be 4 days a week, with a 5th day of retraining/training. So people keep gaining more skills encase technology changes the workforce, and make peoples’ lives more meaningful.
The fifth day should just be free, with training being offered during portions of the year for everyone or as a system similar to, but separate from, vacation days. Imagine a couple weeks in the year where everyone gets together for training or a fairly generous pool of training days to take from and an approved list of courses.
Exactly this! A great example is when the Alberta UCP flat out told renewable energy companies that they just were not allowed to do business in Alberta. Straight up, in your face central planning. Free market indeed…
I’m 100% behind you with this.
And every time I mentioned how it was a bad idea to vote for Carney and how bad he is, I kept being downvoted and then people comment “yeah but we would’ve has Poilievre otherwise.”
No we wouldn’t. A lot of NDP ridings turned red because of this. But people should have voted for the NDP. With them as a strong opposition, we would still be in a better position in a minority big C Conservative government than we are right now with a majority small c conservative government.
Carney is a corporatist. He knows how to sweet talk investors to gain their trust like any CEO can bullshit people into buying their stock. And he’s done that with all of Canada.
Be careful what you wish for…
we would still be in a better position in a minority big C Conservative government than we are right now with a majority small c conservative governent.
You might not have been aware of the full stakes and nuances of the situation in late 2024, early 2025. At around December 2024, Trudeau was so unpopular that Poilievre was in clear majority territory, not minority if an election were held then.
This is more a matter of opinion, and I agree what we have is not a great situation, but do you really think that having Pierre in charge, with a cabinet of emboldened racists and a coalition of a group of conservative Liberals would be better than this? Metaphorically I see it as having Pierre in the driver’s seat with Liberals with them in the front and the NDP backseat driving in the opposition, versus Mark in the front, with the NDP and the Cons together in the back with PP unable to find a compelling message.
Plus, getting Lewis to unapologetically push left-wing ideas for us I think is a better strategy than Singh’s centre-left conciliatory approach that had exhausted its usefulness. The orange wipeout was, rightfully IMO, a wakeup call for the Canadian left.
…the Singh centre-left got lots of stuff done in Canada like a dental plan.
The left needs simpler ideas, like ‘we’ll just hire your kids right out of trade school, and give them a job building 500,000 social housing units’ so they can make money and get experience’.
The left also needs to get tough on crime. Get rid of the violence in prisons by making them safe, but put lots more people behind bars.Agreed with your first and second points, crime definitely is a separate discussion, I’m mixed on that.
Recall that I wrote “…had exhausted its usefulness”, implying it was good, but unlikely to be as effective going forward.
The police forces are controlled by very right wing people, they don’t put any energy into causes that they don’t like, like loud and reckless driving cars.
It would be good to make the police forces more responsive to the communities they serve, but the left has no interest. Legalize drugs, make they only available through license sellers…and go after the unauthorized seller very very very hard, because those people don’t care about you, or making Canada better.but the left has no interest.
You mean the centrist liberals right? Progressives are 100% on board with changing the way law enforcement is done, top to bottom. Its a core of their platform.
Progressives are 100% on board with changing the way law enforcement is done
The left can’t communicate what it wants law enforcement to be.
I am not far left enough to say communism is the right goal, yet, but I am further left than saying we need socialist reforms. I am from Saskatchewan so I can see the benefits of psuedo-socialized markets (think phone and internet with Sasktel sticking it to the big 3) I just wish the rest of the province could see it to. If Saskatchewan can see it and really start celebrating it maybe the rest of Canada could as well.
They all are… That’s the actual goal as we move forward to a new age of complete human ownership via technology attached to government.
The idea of Nation is transitioning out.
Democracy in the entire west is eroding.
Excellent article. Thanks for posting.
Trudeau failure to bring in proportional representation will be a missed opportunity with severe consequences that most don’t fully appreciate.
Trudeau did not fail to bring in proportional representation. He campaigned with the intention of bringing in ranked balloting. Instead of forcing it through when he could, he sent it to committee where no consensus was reached. Instead of compromising with a small improvement the NDP flat out refused anything but proportional representation. With ranked balloting the NDP would consistently win more seats than they do now and we would have more minority governments where compromising would result in more progressive legislation.
Ranked ballots are soooo much better than FPTP, why won’t the NDP and other lefties see that ranked ballots are good. Why/how did proportional representation become a purity test of the ultra left?
This this this. So much this. Canadians do not understand just how catastrophic of a fuckup that was. The consequences of that have not yet been truly felt but it will be horrendous when they are. Canada’s electoral system is a goddamn joke and, in my opinion, is barely even a democracy at all because of it.
Just like the US, we are one 51% vote away from a bad actor gaining absolute power and tearing down everything Canadians have known and loved. Hell, even right now we have a majority government that the people did not vote for.
Our system is better than the US’s system. By just a hair but it is better, but yes we need election reform.
Literally the argument the article is criticizing. Don’t compare one country to another like that. Sure you can take specific examples of how something doesn’t work in certain circumstances, but doing a direct compare just to say “At least we’re not as bad as ____” is ultimately defeatist.
51% vote? More like 38-40% vote. That is all a party typically needs to be able to get a majority government.
Yeah he might’ve fucked the whole country on that one, but now he’s exclusive with Katy Perry so I guess he learned his lesson. /s
And Canadians don’t have the same excuses to not do anything about it unlike the muricans. Their healthcare is not tied to their jobs.
Their healthcare is not tied to their jobs.
sure, if you dont care about your teeth, eyes, mental health, physiotherapy…
All tied to employment…
And before anyone jumps in here with “at least not as bad as america!!!”… thats exactly the kind of low bar thinking that landed us in this situation…
OK. I broke and dislocated my shoulder in 2024. I was in emergency for a while. My open reduction and internal fixation on the left proximal humerus was scheduled fairly quickly. I didn’t have to take out a mortgage for the surgery. I wasn’t financially ruined to get the use of my arm back. If you want teeth, eyes, mental health, and physiotherapy? Be prepared to pay way higher taxes! Your choice….
We’re either paying for it though our job, out of pocket, or through taxes. It’s not free. I’d much rather have it come out of taxes to reduce the middle men just profiteering from our system.
And before anyone jumps in here with “at least not as bad as america!!!”… thats exactly the kind of low bar thinking that landed us in this situation…
Well, look at the bright side: at least you don’t yet have to compare your country with North Korea like Americans do to make it seem less bad.
OK. In 2024 I had an Open Reduction and Internal Fixation on Left Proximal Humerus due to a bad fall. I didn’t lose my house.
Yes. I had one on my ankle last year. I think I paid $200. That wasn’t even to the hospital, is was for my crutches and aircast at the pharmacy.
No, but it is tied to politics. What treatments Canadians have access to is determined by unaccountable appointed bureaucrats at the ministries of health.
As an example, GLP-1 is only available to Canadians who are diagnosed with diabetes. It is not available for general weight loss.
The two aren’t comparable. You really want Doug Ford to decide what and who can be eligible for what treatments, only to have it overturned by the next premier?
Unelected, nonpartisan bureaucracy is what prevents those swings.
But you’re not wrong - Ford is smothering healthcare, as seen by the hospitals struggling with finances right now. Its a problematic sign if most of the major hospitals are all struggling at the same time. Less funds mean poorer service and less availability, and that part is directly driven by politics in the longrun.
You really want Doug Ford to decide what and who can be eligible for what treatments, only to have it overturned by the next premier?
No, the total opposite. I think the government regulation of medicine should be limited to ensuring a drug’s safety, but not efficacy. This was the regime we had decades ago that gave us some of the most useful medications we still have, such as NSAIDs, antibiotics, and many vaccines.
Let me, an individual, decide (along with my doctor) which drugs I should or shouldn’t be taking.
but not efficacy
that’s how you get snake oil
and chemotherapy
you make an adulterous and valid point. godsdamn curing ourselves by poisoning ourselves to death.
Actually, I was referring to how efficacy is not part of the evaluation criteria for chemo drugs.
https://nutritionfacts.org/video/how-effective-is-chemotherapy/
Plenty of that out there already, see the supplements category.
What removal of efficacy requirements does in reality is open the door to a lot more off label use.
You can get the prescription for weight loss in Canada, especially if your current weight puts you at risk. I already know a few people taking the generic for this purpose. Insurance companies are the ones that refuse to provide coverage for anything other than diabetes treatment.
In the US anyone can decide they want to take the drug and just go to one of the websites that advertise all over the place and get a prescription with no issues.
In Canada, if your current weight does not put you at risk but you would still prefer to lose some weight, you’ll have to convince your doctor who may refuse you.
I can’t tell if you think this is a good thing (it is) or a bad thing.
And in the U.S. GLP-1 is only available to U.S. citizens who have enough money to pay for the exorbitant prices. What’s your point?
So I can tell you haven’t been poor recently.
Removed by mod
I actually voted for Mark Carney out of pure fear of what PP would do. But I had no idea it would still turn out this bad.
What turned out so bad?
Mark Carney has spent 24-7 meeting with European countries, creating new trade deals, alleviating the dependence we have on the country that is calling us the “51st state”. I’m down with that :)
He also has been cozying up to the most insane US companies, too. His problem with the US is only that he wants Canada to remain nominally independent while still basically being a fully owned asset of US corporate interest.
In short, its Trump’s wording he is opposed to more than anything. The moment the fucker dies is the moment it is business as usual in his mind.
- Bill C-22… unwarranted surveillance of Canadians
- Promoting environmental destruction through increased O&G production
- Proposed reforms to the Access to Information act to reduce transparency
- Promoting war in Iran
Shall I continue?
And a whole lot of other shit, too.
Removed by mod
Fiscal policies? The guy is basically gutting everything in favor of his rich buddies. You think Doug’s fatass privatization of healthcare is alone to him.
Removed by mod
He is doing none of those things.
Removed by mod
Are you trolling?
Removed by mod
I voted Pierre because the current government intends to criminalize nearly a million people, myself included, for firearms we purchased legally and have been available to the Canadian market since the 70’s.
Say what you want about firearms, the money put into Bill C21 could’ve gone into mental health awareness or increased the budget to the firearms program & RCMP detachments performing background checks, hell I think an improved Canadian Firearms Safety Course is about due with stricter requirements.
UK and Germany’s too. Hungary, France, Denmark and Italy also not in great shape. Anywhere there’s heavy zionist genocider influence campaigns. Coincidence maybe. Spain and Ireland are doing great as an anti-pattern.
The richest man in the world does a Nazi salute and you think “it must be the Jews behind all of the problems”?
High chance Elon is pro-Israel. It’s a symptom, not the disease.
A pro Israel Nazi? Confusing.
What? Where did they say that? They’re talking about Israel.
They weren’t taking about “the Jews”. They were talking about genocidal, racest, apartidests that are interfering in other countries elections.
You don’t have to get pissy because they didn’t list everyone in that category.
Well, there was one country who was very adamant about not having neonazis next door…
“Quietly”?
Democracy IS THE COMPROMISE.
The alternative is a nonstop threat of violence that makes the “Wild West” look like a monk’s retreat.
The ‘Wild West’ wasn’t all that wild or lawless https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cR7EBBXcQUg it was probably safer than life today in Canada. Don’t let all the dumb Hollywood movies fool you.
Actually, this is not about Canada, this is about the world. And it’s frightening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=Fd-_VDYit3U&ra=m
I’m a bit put off by our rating now placing behind Brazil as I’m pretty sure in practical terms Canada is still more Democratic in many aspects. Does it mean we’re not sliding? I’m certain we are,but I think methodology might be flawed and as a result we’ve got sensational-ish content.
TBF - yes democracy is sliding in Canada, just look at recent government moves i Quebec and Alberta as a sample. Meaning we have to fight for it at the polls and on the streets. It’s far from “game over” but it could be at some point.
I’m pretty sure in practical terms Canada is still more Democratic in many aspects
I’m not as familiar with either system as you seem to be. What is it about Brazilian politics that makes you feel Canada is more democratic?
we can start with favellas which have no equivalent in Canada (treatment of indigenous people is a separate issue and looks to be similarly bad in both cases). Then we can look at Brazilian latest election scandals etc. which have no equivalents in modern Canadian elections. Then we can look at corruption levels in politics.
So the favelas are bad, obviously, but I don’t quite see the relation to democracy. They’re certainly an indicator of poverty, but I’m not entirely sure what they indicate regarding democracy.
Then we can look at Brazilian latest election scandals etc.
I don’t really know about these scandals, but when I think about other scandals surrounding elections, they’re not necessarily an indictment of the democratic system itself, right? I mean, Trump clearly disputed the election results of the 2020 election, but does that mean the election was unfair? But in all honesty, I haven’t looked at their latest election scandals, and you seem to have looked at it, so maybe you know better. What was the latest election scandal?
Then we can look at corruption levels in politics.
I suppose we could. Did you? Is it worse in Brazil?
favella dwellers are people with virtually no rights, i.e. no “democracy” for them, fact that someone would weaponize democratic processes to get rid of democracy is the problem with latest scandals. In terms of corruption, anecdotally I hear stories from (ex)Brazilians that I cannot draw parallels to in Canada
The tipping point has been reached. It’s time to usher in the next phase of human existence with a universally global benevolent dictatorship. Democracy was good to a certain point but now we are a world of dangerous fools electing dangerous fools to “lead” us. We need a serious thinking adult in the room again.
After 10 years of Trump and barely a year of Carney, anyone who says ‘we need a businessman and not a politician’ should be locked up in solitary confinement for 20 years minimum.
Fuck business, I’m more for humanity and ecology.
Exactly. This whole ‘we need a businessman’ line was originally started by Ross Perot in the 90s. To be honest, it only would make sense if you know nothing about public vs. private infrastructure and profit vs. ‘this is lossy, but critical’.
For example healthcare… I hate to say it, you cannot make money off healthcare without being extremely predatory and evil. this isn’t me being idealistic and somehow refusing to believe you can be ‘good’ while maintaining a for-profit model. YOU CANNOT MAKE HEALTHCARE PROFITABLE WITHOUT BEING EVIL!
The reason? Despite it being absolutely critical, healthcare and insurance is going to need a ton of money to maintain, and unless you’re denying healthcare most of the time (and only partially covering the other) you will lose money. You know the private for-profit healthcare clinics that have been popping up in Canada over the past few decades? They deliver less results and cost more public money than public clinics do. Yes, they’re getting taxpayer dollars, a lot of them, and STILL can’t turn a profit.
If you said ‘no more public healthcare, all private now, but they need to stand up on their own two feet’ most of them would collapse within a few years. Because no matter how important this shit is, they can’t be profitable. So they are given public money that they pocket themselves while still failing to provide the services demanded.
when I was more naive I would ask ‘but why not just make it all public? It’ll be cheaper? and make it easier to be a doctor and give more grants to medical students and learning?’ But now I know the reason answer… because it would benefit a few people (double digit numbers at the most) over the millions below. That’s it. It is such an intensely simple way to look at it.
This is why Elon Musk becoming a trillionaire is one of the worst things to happen so far, because he is far from the first. The others are racing for trillionaire spots. What this means is basically they don’t just control the economy of entire countries and can fully bypass any government they want, but they basically control the entire world.
You mean like a billionaire, who is thus uninterested in money, is anti establishment, pledges to get rid of the corruption of politics, seems to be closer to understanding poor people and getting along with them? We have one, and he’s absolutely the worst president ever.
Edit: I also think that mostly applies to Germany in the past on führer contemplation.
It’s happening all across the west








