I understand you’re making a point, but it’s not a good one. Yes, you can create a thought experiment where the trolley can be teleported into another dimension. Is that a worthwhile thought experiment? Probably not. But that doesn’t mean that creating variations of established thought experiments is inherently invalid.
I understand you’re making a point, but it’s not a good one. Yes, you can create a thought experiment where the trolley can be teleported into another dimension. Is that a worthwhile thought experiment? Probably not. But that doesn’t mean that creating variations of established thought experiments is inherently invalid.
It’s no more worthwhile than this meme