- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
Are we witnessing the IBMification of Microsoft?
I’ve heard this many times before:
The announcement is a striking inversion of how we’ve traditionally used software.
Think of it like concept cars. Sure, some features make it into production, but much of the time, you never see that shit again.
Microsoft will try this as a way to make more money, and when it inevitably doesn’t work out, will back off and try another avenue.
That’s just how companies work.
So get out all your energy and waste all your time worrying about this. Nothing significant will come of it.
This is the Microsoft way, throw lots of money at a problem without thinking through the solution first.
Crap Pilot is not used by me unless it is forced on me.
Can’t be forced on you if you’re not on Windows
I’d call it a heap of giant fuckups waiting to happen.
What will happen first? An Email agent happily transferring a companies cash reserves to some scammer? Destruction of vital production databases? “Loss” of production secrets or fiinancial details by AI putting it on the web site?
Nobody asked for this. Why is Microsoft doing things nobody asked for?
I’m wondering if this change isn’t for all of us that know how to do things without AI, but rather the next generation that is growing up with AI. They don’t know how to do what we do, but they do know how to ask ChatGPT to do something.
After growing up and being in school using AI to do all your homework, it doesn’t look so crazy that that generation will carry that habit into the workplace and use and LLM chatbot as their primary interface for all their work.
Every organization is trying to predict the future and Microsoft is simultaneously trying to get their investors excited. You can’t do that with iterations in the AI age. You have to do it by completely destroying your product and/or userbase it seems.
This is pretty much th right answer. Number must go up, so companies do whatever they think will make number go up.
When number not go up, they will move on to the next thing.
Because billing. Because executives are too often paid to change things.

Corpospeak was more bearable before chief executives started describing things as an OS that aren’t an OS.
A few weeks ago I was at a conference listening to a dude from Google talk about Chrome.
Every time he said Chrome, he added “which is the operating system”.
I think they all just want to be gatekeepers as they are not really delivering much value.
Yes, Microsoft, exactly what we asked for. We love it when you take ownership over all our enterprise data and processes. Obviously you will compensate us whenever anything goes wrong, and you certainly won’t use your position to predict or control markets, will you?
The fucking hubris on this clowns is insufferable. Why is ANYONE going along with this?
In 2028 when AOC is president, she needs to put Lina Khan tasked directly with breaking up every single major tech company starting with Google and Microsoft, and moving swiftly to OpenAI and Anthropic. Palantir can be MOAB’d.
“When AOC is president” I really admire your optimism. I’d love this, but given recent events, and the US voting population, I’m not confident.
It’d be rad to have fdr 2.0 coupled with someone willing to break up all of these monopolies
I hate you so much for being someone I agree with so wholeheartedly.
And I thought shit couldn’t get shittier
Microsoft is fascinating to me because they seem to operate on some sort of magic whereby they’ll make the shittiest possible version of everything (as in, shittier than you can even imagine the shittiest version of something being) and yet it always becomes the standard default version used by everyone.
What I find especially interesting about Microsoft products is that there are hidden depths of shittiness, as if someone’s put a lot of thought and care into it. Like, you’ll get some new Microsoft product and you look at it, and it looks kind of shitty which is standard. Then you’ll go to do something basic and find out that function is not there, or it’s implemented in the strangest way possible and you’ll think “Oh, that’s shitty.” Then there’s an odd lull where you get used to the surface-level shittiness and sort of work around it’s quirks, so you stop thinking about it.
Then, something will break. Usually in some minor way that quickly escalates until you have to try and figure it out, and then when you start to take the lid off the thing you’ll invariably discover something in the inner workings that is so utterly and unbelievably stupid that for a brief moment you can’t even be angry.
As an example, my experience of setting up Windows 11, thankfully not on my own computer:
-
Install Windows 11. Hmm, looks kind of shitty as expected.
-
Create a system restore point, assuming that Windows 11 will fuck itself up fairly immediately.
-
Click on a .jpg. Immediate pop-up asking me what to do with it. Okay, that’s a nice shitty detail. I suggest that Windows uses it’s own built-in image viewer to view this image, and then suggest it a second time for the next image. After this it seems to get the idea.
-
Repeat this process for a .zip file, which is something it also has a built-in tool for.
-
Set up a few things, install some apps from the MS store. This is the lull.
-
Windows then throws some sort of licensing spaz, declares that all the apps I installed from the MS store are invalid, and for some reason can now never be reinstalled again. Cool cool.
-
Windows then declares that the solution for this is to reinstall Windows from scratch. Nicely unhelpful! Luckily, I anticipated this and made a system restore point when it was a clean install.
-
I go to restore this (this is the under-the-hood part) and discover that Windows only keeps one restore point, which it decides is just the last time it did anything. Meaning you can set a manual restore point and Windows, silently in the background without asking, will proceed to fuck itself up and then throw out your restore point and save it’s fuck up as the only restore point. I wasn’t even mad. That is such a colossal misunderstanding of the entire purpose of save points, user-friendliness and general logic that I actually laughed. Then deleted the whole thing.
Even just day-to-day, after years of having to use Windows for work, I discover new and delightful little shitty surprises. The latest one: when it asks for admin permissions (which it does for ludicrous things such as deleting a shortcut from the desktop, which it put there without asking for admin permission, or any permission) the request for admin permission arrives as a popup box, which does not automatically grab focus. So, if you’re not paying attention or you expect it to behave like any other popup box that’s ever existed, including other ones from Microsoft, you end up typing your admin password into whatever was open when it popped up. Which can lead to, for example, posting your admin password to the group Slack channel.
They really do seem to think of everything.
This one hit hard!!!
I find most of that in work laptop …. The lack of permission to delete shortcut OR EVEN TO MOVE ALL THE DESKTOP SHORTCUT FILES TO A FOLDER is nerve wrecking.
Your comment deserves an award!! | | O
[gold medal]
-
A shart in the wind.
I’m ready to run a schistopad on libre and move to an abandoned shack in the woods.
The article is soo full of buzzwords I had flashbacks to 2008.
Microsoft talking utter nonsense as usual. How can an AI chatbot be an OS??
Anything is possible if only you would readjust your expectations ;)
Instead of opening a program by clicking on an icon, I say “open outlook” and then it sends that recording to a data center, turns it into text, feeds it into a harness wrapping an LLM, which then runs remote commands on my PC to find any program starting with “out”, the finally selects the program to open.
What would have been a short interaction with minimal chance to collect telemetry has now become a much richer source of data for MS to sell.
Why don’t you think about the shareholders instead of just yourself Mr Selfish /s
It’s cute you still think you’ll have a “computer” that “launches programs” and not just a tablet that is streaming a remote session to you.
You know, so your data is “safe”, and your “experience” is “quality controlled”.
Bah, Icons are so old school, just do windows Key, then type “out” and press return.
Windows circled back from its identity of everything relying on a GUI to replacing its menus with a basic shell prompt.
Get with the times, it’s called “vibe-wording”. Anything can be called an OS if you really want it.
And anything can be Copilot if you’re Microsoft. I’m just waiting for them to release Copilot for Copilot, which will help a lot with integrating Copilot with Copilot, especially for companies that have a 360 Copilot Live 365 subscription.
Copilot Live 364 subscription *
Is it Operating? Is it a System? There technically correct, ugh
Is it Operating
That part is debatable
They didn’t say it operates well
Jesus fucking christ. I’d heard about that but didn’t watch the video until now; I didn’t realize they meant “hallucinated in real-time with no code behind the UI!”
“what’s a workflow? Muscle memory? Never heard of it”
Viewed as satire, this is my favourite thing
Oooft. Thanks I hate it
Copilot Autopilot (not to be confused with Windows Autopilot)
First fix your naming conventions you fucking morons.
Like “windows app”. wtf. What a terrible, unsearchable pos name that is!
Pffft, how could you confuse them, when one has TWICE as much “pilot” as the other!? Really flows off the tongue, that brand name.
They deliberately do this. Like they have 2 outlook apps. Their remote desktop app on a mac is called windows. Etc.
Windows App is the name for their remote desktop app which both does citrix-y remote app access and full remote desktop.
There’s also Windows Runtime apps which are those WinRT things you get from Microsoft Store which were supposed to run on phones, tablets, PC and Xbox, but now you only know them as the weird bloat games on a new PC.
Don’t forget outlook.com, the rebranded hotmail.com.
And now it’s not New Outlook, is got another rebrand Outlook for Windows for W11 25H2.
And all the Xbox One, Xbox One X, Xbox Series S, and Xbox Series X nonsense.
USB 2x2 5Gbps Gen 3.7
I still have no idea which X Box is which. Why can’t they just go with Xbox 2, Xbox 3, Xbox 4?

While I definitely would prefer if everyone switched over to LibreOffice and .ods files I find that the the onlyoffice fork euro-office is much easier to move to if you’re used to Microsoft Excel, similar handling of tables, sorting and filtering and such.
https://github.com/Euro-Office/DesktopEditors/releases/That’s cool. It looks like Euro-Office is kind of the same project as Nexcloud-Office. Is that right?
People should use OpenDocument files even if they’re editing them with MS Office. That should just be a fucking basic expectation at this point even before you start talking about switching programs.
Seconded on ONLYOFFICE.
https://linuxiac.com/fsf-says-onlyoffice-cannot-use-agpl-to-restrict-forks/
Onlyoffice is doing shenanigans with licenses
I want a Google office suite clone instead.
Realistically, Word is way more complicated than most people need, and real time collaboration plus reviews and change tracking are 100x more valuable.
Same goes for PowerPoint and Excel (grist is unusable as a substitute due to security and licensing).
Word sucks. It just is not good at letting people know what they are interacting with, clicking into a template is not obvious and can cause issues.
So does excel, I realised yesterday I cant click and drag to increase a number if I have any filter at all on.
I do not get the love for Excel. I get that it can do anything and is very flexible, but the UI is terrible.
Click a filter, get an unintuitive filter list. Filters appear over the cell awkwardly, pivot table interactions are insane, with nested menus to manage formatting and such.
What do those people who need that complexity use? Why would you argue that less is more?
And why would you want software delivered over the web?
Fuck all of that.
Adobe InDesign is great for complex document layouts. (just don’t give them any money lol 🏴☠️)
LaTeX or Adobe InDesign/Scribus, depending on what you’re doing. Microsoft Publisher used to be the MS tool, but it’s discontinued.
It exists - e.g Collaboration or Nextcloud Office
Even Proton Docs and Sheets are clones.
Huh, I’ll check that out
I still think the UI on Gsuite is better than MS Office, which I find terminally over complicated. But that is a good improvement
So much of my screen is “toolbar”. Why is there a huge search bar in the document.
Undo and redo used to be side by side. Now it is undo and drop down menu to reveal a single option…redo.
Yeah, I just think how many users are hitting 5% of these buttons on any given document?
Individually, yes, these are all features and someone will use them. But like, can we clean this up a bit?

Contrast that with Pages, which I know has has issues but is a pretty good user experience

There’s got to be a better middle ground between full on print-publishing like Adobe Indesign and low-touch online collaboration like Google Docs
I know the ribbon view makes things a little more modal, but it’s not quite there.
I know you can customize Libre Office, but it’s also a much worse appearance

Anyways, this is turning into an essay.
(all the screenshots I pulled from the Libre Office manual)
So, as a devout AI-refuser, does that mean I’m now entirely banned from M365 at work, despite the fact that I filed a religious exemption, it was approved, and my copilot license was revoked?
Does that mean anything?
Does my autonomy mean anything?
No
Religious exemption to technology, is this an amish thing?




















