The reality is setting in that people simply do not care about making the world a better place. It is breaking my heart, and I do not know how to reconcile my thoughts. I’m sorry to be such a downer here but I don’t know where else to share.
Perhaps the climate catastrophe, human suffering, and inequality is so large and so much out of people’s hands that even people who care have come to a state of learned helplessness. However, there are things within people’s control that doesn’t change. At work, I listen to a coworker frustrated about a simple problem. It would be a simple change to make this person’s job much less painful, but he “just works here”. It’s just such a dumb problem to waste hours of someone’s life on. To a certain extent, I can’t blame him, because a lot of people just work to survive.
I want to make the world a better place. A world where people have all there basic needs met, live in balance with nature, and have a right to self determination. A world where humanity strives to be the best version of itself. I can’t help but get sad or frustrated when I see something wrong. I can’t help but feel like I’m a downer to my friends when I point these things out. They don’t disagree with me, but it just seems like a depressing topic. People seem generally content to live their normal lives. In the same way, I can’t blame them. It won’t build a better future, but they deserve to be happy.
Maybe my coworkers are right, and that I’m too naïve. Maybe my friends are right, and that I’m too empathetic for my own good. I am envious that they can turn off the thing in their head that worries, or wants to make things better, and that they can just enjoy life. A more utopian future is generations away, or maybe never. If I can’t effect change, maybe I should find an outlet, or stop caring, or something. idk, sorry for yapping. if you’re reading this i hope you have a good day
I think of it as situational, in your orbit, you have coworkers wasting time on simple problems. In other parts of the world, in remote villages, solar is changing people’s lives for the better.
I have known too many people lost in their own bubbles of reality, never considering the larger picture and impacts of personal choices. They are the majority, unfortunately.
Just focus on what you can do for yourself, find like minded people to share on larger efforts, and don’t waste your own time and energy (especially emotional) on people that never put in a second thought into efforts for improving the world.
I’d argue they don’t care because they aren’t issued the resources necessary to care. Our workers also don’t have enough time / energy to parent or to engage in their civic duties of working out what is in their best interests and voting accordingly. Let alone the impetus to imagine a better world and strive for it.
It’s difficult to say if this was intentional all along, or just a happy(?) accident of overworking our labor force out of sheer greed,¹ but it belies the drift of abusive systems towards greater dysfunction, which is why we need ironclad protections against labor abuse.
Not that we’re going to get it necessarily without blood…or with blood for that matter. It’s why violent revolution is on the table since the masses can’t afford the time and energy to conduct non-violent protest.
I’d credit our oppressors for being thorough, but they really aren’t all that bright, so I no longer give them the benefit of the doubt.
¹ We now have studies that show a well-treated labor force is worth the extra expense, from sheer productivity increase alone. Our upper management is just too short-sighted, too divisionist and too paranoid to bother to make their companies worth putting the effort in for, even though optimizing for profit is their job description.
have come to a state of learned helplessness
I think it’s the reverse. The problems you talk about are too large and abstract for most people. They worry about more important things such as the new Taylor Swift album.
@iii @aka i think what people need are the tools to imagine what can change. We specifically created https://storyseedlibrary.org/ for that :)
Nice site, and nice idea! Bookmarked.
You should make a community here on lemmy for it, I have loads of questions and I bet I’m not the only one!
@Valmond feel free to ask them, I’m over here on Mastodon. I’m not experienced in Lemmy spaces, do you think that setting slrpnk.net/c/storySeedLibrary would make sense?
Speaking for myself, I’d love to see a StorySeedLibrary community here on slrpnk, if it’s something you’d be interested in :)
Link seems okay if you create the community there.
Where are you guys hanging out on mastodon? I’m not vell versed in mastodon :-)
@Valmond we mostly hang around #solarpunk and #storySeedLibrary tags
Thanks, is checking out!
@Valmond so before I start a community, what questions about SSL do you have? :)
Sadly a lot of people just didn’t care about anything unless it directly effects them. I feel for ya but remember to take care of yourself, friends and family first. Do the things you love. Oh and build some kind of solar device that saves you thousands. Your friend might listen then.
For you my friend, I recommend the book “climate, psychology, and change” I hold this one close to my heart.
Whenever I’m struggling with the fact that everything is bullshit, I try to remind myself that there isn’t that much stopping me from living my own life as if I was already living after the revolution, or in utopia, or after the apocalypse, or whatever you want to call it or think it might be. Ultimately, I want to hang out with my dogs, garden, hike, cook, listen to and play music, hang out with friends, run rivers, ski, etc. etc. All achievable now, mostly. Do I also have to do bullshit I don’t want to? Sure. Are a lot of other people living in a crappy way and doing stupid and destructive bullshit? Definitely. But for the most part, if you just do what you can and try to live your life as if you already won the war, it’s pretty ok.
People are simply shutting down their head. If you can’t see it, it doesn’t exist.
When I was a kid I really thought the leisure society will happen. Now I’m simply counting down the years to death.
I have been going through a very similar experience to you. The more coworkers I have over the years, the more people I realize are extremely jaded and having a tough time caring at all about the world at large.
This is a pretty complicated issue. I think that means you need a sort of patchwork of paradigms to apply to the issue at the right moment.
Sometimes you need to give yourself a break and let yourself live your life - you only get one, and joy is an essential part of a functioning human, and you must continue to function if you are to continue impacting your world.
Other times you must keep in mind that it is literally completely illogical to say that your actions have no impact, obviously each individual action on it’s own is small but the actions humanity makes are made up of individuals. Change happens one person at a time, and individuals are difference-makers.
Consider professional sports teams where the stars elevate the team to the next level - they cannot do their work by themselves, every member of the team is needed and makes an impact, but the impacts are not all the same. You will see the same dynamic play out in the typical workplace - a relatively small portion of people really make things happen at most workplaces in my experience, but they still need the team to help them get it done. So you should continue to think of your actions as being important/having meaning in my opinion, and you should keep striving to make the world a better place.
Sometimes when there is a situation that frustrates me but that I know I cannot change (or cannot change immediately or in full), it helps to quiet that thing in my head that worries by practicing mindfulness techniques. Personally I find “box breathing” (a style of controlling breathing to regulate heart rate and perhaps lower cortisol) to be most effective. Maybe this or some other method could help to quel your feelings when you know that it is a situation to let go of.
Just do what you can do to make things better for people. It’ll drive you crazy if you’re worrying about what other people are doing. Even crazier than that if you want a reward for doing things right. Do the right thing (even if no one else is) simply because it’s the right thing to do.
Serenity is to accept the things you cannot change, the courage to change the things you can, and the wisdom to know the difference.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I know there are many people feeling similar. And I have some thoughts that help me not to give up hope.
- change doesn’t come fast, it’s growing slowly under the actions small or big of people who want it.
- there are likeminded people in the world. We are not the majority but we are not alone
- there is no alternative to aim for a better, healthier world. Even if it looks dark, giving up is not an option
- go on your own pace. Small steps can make the difference. Don’t expect major changes. Revolutions happen once in 100 years, even less I guess.
- find at least one or two friends or comrades who share your values. Join a union or a political movement, try to engage and find your place.
This is great advice! It took me a couple of decades and I’m still struggling sometimes, but this is the way. It is a burden and a privilege to recognize a deep-seated social or environmental problem because you can now spend the rest of your life telling people about it and get hit with ignorance, apathy or some sort of bullshit bingo. It will crush you if you don’t find strategies to deal with that. The post I’m replying to are exactly the strategies I would recommend as well. It’s not easy because it’s (too) slow and not as sexy as calling for a revolution. But I’d say it’s the only way. Lead by example.
Well … and sabotage. You should definitely blow up some pipelines.
It is a burden and a privilege
You explained the burden part, but forgot to explain why it’s also a privilege.
It’s like everyone is in the fog of lost souls from Legend of Korra, and we’re the ones that can see through it. When you have a working brain, you can make the right choices. You can guarantee your life is meaningful, because you’re not blindly using random dice rolls to determine that - you’re using your brain to make choices based on the meaningful information available to you. This makes every day deeply different for us.
I’m outnumbered by people who can kill me any time, but they can’t make it mean anything, or stop me from doing so, because I’m the one with an actual mental model of the world to make choices from.
Boiling away all the poetic wording, the simple truth is: the world is sick, and we have been spared the worst of the sickness. What a gift.
I think the crux of the issue is that positive change is slow, but negative change can sweep through and more than remove those gains at what seems to be a moment’s notice.
If you want to improve things you can’t wait around for a good moment or depend on the involvement of the depoliticized and hopeless to join in. You can just do things. There are other people doing things, too and you can find them. The change you make can inspire some others too, but the disaffected will always be frustrating to see and deal with. There will always be more to do but the thing is to keep trying to move toward the ideal even if it’s just by inches and there’s miles to go, it’s the long haul
There are other people doing things, too and you can find them.
Short guide for how to find those like-minded folk: https://infosec.exchange/@tinker/113589807117870451
This is a remarkable amount of main character syndrome, frankly. It doesn’t read like excess empathy to me, it reads like privilege.
You’re not saving the world. You’ll never be saving the world. Your contribution either way is irrelevant. The big problems that you are frustrated about are about mass incentives, big numbers and geopolitics, not about people coming together for the common good because they care so much. It’s not naïveté, it’s arrogance. You get to vote on the big overall direction and, if you have the time, resources and disposition, to collaborate in activism with millions of others, assuming enough of them agree with you.
The small stuff? The “I could do this marginally better for mine or someone else’s sake”? That’s worth it. That you can do yourself. It still works on the same set of incentives and dynamics, but if it’s something you personally can do to make something marginally better for someone, then… you know… go ahead? It’s just much more valuable to do it in your own life than to get frustrated by someone else who you think should do it. Because, again, you aren’t that important. Nobody is waiting for your command or judgement unless you’re supposed to be giving it for some reason.
And let me be clear, I’m not mad about this. I’m not outraged at your worldview or anything. It’s just that, honestly, in good faith, I think this sense of despair at everybody else refusing to fix things by acting as a hive mind with your same set of values and priorities is not a problem of ethics as much as a problem of narcissism and an inflated sense of one’s own impact, and both that individual and their surroundings are better served by understanding the actual scale of their agency. Because… you know, that way you don’t get discouraged when it comes to doing the small things you can do on the large scale, like voting or protesting, and you don’t get angry about doing the big things you can do in the small scale, like not being an asshole or being too deflated to actually act in the spaces you control.
So no hard feelings but this is a get over yourself moment. In a constructive, positive, agency-filled, collaborative, collective action-driven way.
I don’t really feel like talking about it, but I’m just going to note that I strongly disagree with your opinion in this post. I think it’s natural to experience existential dread over how little our actions matter in the grand scheme of things, and wonder whether our fellow human beings - or ourselves - are worth the effort. I do not think it’s arrogance, privilege or narcissism to feel that way. If someone had suggested that to me back when I was in OP’s position, I would have slipped even deeper into despair. I’m not attacking you here, I just want to point out that there is space for different perspectives here.
I’m not attacking you here
I find it really sad that you’re not attacking the person you replied to, when they are quite brutally attacking someone vulnerable.
Also sad that they have a multi-point-positive vote score.
Glad I’m not the only one to at least call them out at all, though.
I’m not attacking the OP.
I’m arguing the sense of despair they feel is a consequence of an inflated sense of their own individuality and relevance.
The problem with being stuck in that spiral is that if you parse being told you’re not in charge of saving the world single-handedly as an attack you’re locking yourself from getting out of that spiral, and if you don’t break out of thinking you’re in charge of saving the world single-handedly you also get stuck in that spiral.
So hey, is it a harsh thing to hear? Probably. But also, if you go on the Internet to ask about it, maybe hearing it isn’t the worst thing that can happen to you as a result. It’s likely better than some pity party about how the world is going to end because everybody is evil, which is, frankly, probably a terrible thing to do to a person coming at you from that perspective.
@girlthing @MudMan
I very much agree to your criticism. It is not that we expect everyone to not care about their problems and instead focus in the ones we deem big, it is about other people, who could have the power to change stuff, just ignore or counteract factually important things.
No one expects someone who is hungry to not try to get food. We expect other privileged to act rational. To protect their own, their families or the society they depend on interests. But they just do not.
You’re not saving the world. You’ll never be saving the world. Your contribution either way is irrelevant.
Why are you rage baiting in a place where people can get banned for giving you the kind of reply you deserve?
Rhetorical question, obviously.
See, the irony of this comment is that projecting some entirely made up narrative onto the motivations of other people is exactly the sort of self-destructive self-righteousness that seems to be harming the OP in the first place.
FWIW, I had in no way considered the moderation policy of this “place”, whichever "place you’re referring to, at all.
But feel free to reach out to me privately to give me whatever reply you think I “deserve”. Which is also some chilling degree of self-righteousness, frankly. You’re not social media Batman doing justice by insulting people, along with the rest of world saving that’s not on you or the OP.
Not reading this. Feel free to start this discussion with me on nostr, where there are no bans, if you have a spine
“A spine” as opposed to… being afraid that you’re mean to me?
I mean, I’ve been around. I think I can picture worse than you can do by talking to me, going by our interaction so far.
Also, the idea of “meet me behind the gym” but with Nostr is just about the most hilarious thing I’ve read on social media. We live in the dumbest dystopia. OP may have been correct for the wrong reasons.
Happy for you or sorry that happened or whatever
A little bit harsh maybe but oh so truthful IMO for many many people (I don’t know OP BTW, hang in there OP!).
Most people gets programmed for life in their young years; religion, must work hard my whole life, narcissism, … And you can’t really change that it seems. I mean you can’t change them but we can change the system so that the future generations have a more open mind and can chose more for themselves.
Or so I believe.
It’s very cultural, and not necessarily a deliberate impossition, either. I definitely see the whole main character thing more in Americans and some northern Europeans.
You can err on the other side, too. People can feel powerless enough to never take action against their own oppression, ro to the point where they find their own corruption doesn’t matter because everybody does the same thing and their own principles will have no impact.
Both are disproportionate, though. You aren’t in charge of saving the world, but you do have some agency and a responsibility about how you use it. It does take some distance to have some perspective on the battles where you’re supposed to do your part even if you’re not winning them.
I think most ppl do want to make the world a better place, but most ppl give up very easily, because they have urgent personal matters to deal with as well. Most think often about how they can help fixing the world, but they can only do so much every day, so they are like “It’s a shame I can only use rechargable batteries and plant wild flowers for the bees, but my taxes aren’t gonna file themselves.”
deleted by creator








