help-circle



  • Illegal prison found in Kyiv, 14-year-old boy freed | Al Bawaba

    Expand

    An illegal, secret prison was found on Monday near Kiev in Ukraine, and a 14-year-old boy was detained inside the detention facility in the Petropavlivska Borshchahivka area.

    The secret prison is linked to Azov Corps, which is a formation within the Ukrainian National Guard, amid disturbing reports of torture and the unlawful imprisonment of people.

    Horrific videos emerged online, and Ukrainians are furious after the evacuation of a 14-year-old boy from the illegal prison. In the footage, the teenager was seen being escorted from the property.

    Azov Corps confirmed that one of its military units operated at the location, where multiple wounded servicemen were also found inside the building.

    On the other hand, Kirill Budanov, the head of the office of the president of Ukraine, arrived at the scene where military personnel were being held.

    Street protests erupted upon the arrival of Budanov, and gunfire was heard. In addition, people used pepper spray against the official, according to the Ukrainian Independent Information Agency via Telegram.

    According to the Azov Corps’ statement on Nov. 2, information began to emerge online about the alleged torture of servicemen inside a building. After that, civilians gathered, urging the police and security forces to intervene.

    At least four of the soldiers who were detained after committing a disciplinary offense had wounded and hospitalized for medical treatment. The rest of the people who were found inside the building were evacuated.


    Former spy chief of the Kiev régime and now head of Zelensky’s office, Budanov:

    “There are many such places in Ukraine.”

    https://nitter.catsarch.com/I_Katchanovski/status/2117387899628884050

    The paramedic who reported this facility to the police has already been arrested. Another medic is already receiving death threats, including from AFU and NGU commanders.

    Azov commander Prokopenko recorded a video accusing those who exposed the secret torture prison of smearing the military, discrediting Azov and helping Russia to destabilize Ukraine.

    The official Kiev regime talking point is now that this was “a Russian operation”. How the Russians were operating a torture dungeon in Kiev staffed by Ukrainians for Ukrainians, is unclear.

    Here are some more Ukrainian journalists and commentators (all now labeled enemies of the Zelensky regime) posting about this story if you want to follow their updates:

    https://nitter.catsarch.com/anatoliisharii/status/2117316179719004250

    https://nitter.catsarch.com/Panchenko_X/status/2117297391258767461

    https://nitter.catsarch.com/HavryshkoMarta/status/2117349323448983881

    In case anyone is surprised by this, here’s a little history lesson:

    One of the first things Azov ever did was occupy Mariupol, murder civilians and set up a torture prison (most infamously at Mariupol airport, where an estimated 1,500 people were tortured and killed). That was back in 2014, over twelve years ago. By 2022 they had several black sites all over eastern Ukraine where they tortured “separatists” accused of being pro-Russian (and also for “regular” criminal purposes like extortion). Why is anyone surprised. Well, the last few years they’re allowed to kidnap and torture everyone else, too, I guess.


  • the problem is that you are holding yourself to an idealist standard.

    as i said in a previous comment, we should reject the leap from “i (marginally) benefit from an unjust system” to “i should hate myself, and people harmed by that system should condemn me as a person.”

    guilt isn’t the same as accountability. feeling bad may acknowledge harm, but self-condemnation by itself leads to nothing good and only causes harm to yourself and the movement. a more useful question is: “what do i participate in, what power do i have, and what can i do with others to change it?” that points towards political solidarity and material change, rather than treating self-hatred as proof of moral seriousness.

    “i’d condemn myself in their shoes” is projection, not evidence. it assumes people harmed by imperialism would all respond alike, and that your imagined reaction tells you what they actually think. people in the global south are not a single moral tribunal. some may (in my opinion wrongly) view you with dislike; others may be more intelligent and focus criticism on actual governments, companies, institutions, or particular actions. their views deserve to be heard as specific views, not guessed at or generalised.

    don’t make harmed people responsible for condemning or absolving you! listen to particular people and movements without expecting moral judgement or expecting one person to speak for everyone. take criticism seriously, but don’t turn it into a verdict that you are irredeemably bad.

    you are not guilty by birth or geography! you don’t need to hate yourself to oppose imperialism. you only need to understand your position, listen without expecting to be judged on moral grounds, and act with others against the structures causing harm.



  • marxism is not moralism; it does not demand of us to swear a moral oath and uphold it like some kind of political vestal virgins. when lenin was in switzerland, he still ate, did he not?

    yes, on a rational level, we may analyse how our own consumption affects others, and it is indeed correct to try to reduce harm to the best of one’s ability, but ultimately individualist approaches are ineffective compared with systemic ones, and self-flagellation is an individualist approach.

    you did not create or choose colonialism, or unequal exchange! any benefit you may receive from its existence does not paper over the fact that you are yourself exploited and have a common class interest with all other workers on this planet, not to mention the fact that the main cause of harm and the main benefactor of those systems is not you, but the capitalist!

    also, i would like to push back against the notion that people in the first world have been “given” the benefits from capitalism:

    The truth is, that nothing was ever given to you. The founding fathers didn’t give you your rights! Women weren’t given the right to vote! You always hear [that] women were given the right to vote with the 19th Amendment. Women struggled for a hundred years. For a hundred years, from the 1820s when they mobilised the first convention—and by the way, the vote wasn’t even their major demand—they had a whole host of demands related to the treatment of women, labour and child labour, property rights, inheritance rights, and all that sort of thing, including legal rights.

    Women struggled for a hundred years; they agitated, marched, got arrested, beaten up, roughed up, and chained themselves to the White House gates. They were thrown into jail; some of them died of pneumonia, were force-fed, and endured all manner of brutal treatment. Only after a hundred years of struggle were they “given” the vote—this great gradualist process.

    […] Workers were not given free trade unions either; they had to fight for them. They had to fight against goon squads, Pinkerton detectives, terrorists, state militia, the National Guard, and the US Army. And that is how they achieved it, with their blood and their struggle.

    –michel parenti

    even third-worldist analysis does not condemn global-north workers morally! it merely seeks to analyse, explain, and criticise certain political realities and bring to light the additional difficulties and injustices third-world people have to face. but no global-south revolutionary would ever deny you the title of worker or perceive you as an enemy on the same level as they perceive the capitalist.

    to love and help others, it is helpful to love and help yourself.



  • self-hatred is counter-productive!

    please don’t fall into the liberal-moralist trap of believing a socially produced injury to be your personal defect. you did not choose the material conditions you live under! could the average russian worker be blamed for not having achieved as much as lenin?

    i understand that in our ideological drive and conviction, we sometimes ask ourselves the impossible, but ironically, this is capitalist indoctrination talking: it is capitalism that pushes us into thinking that only our productive output matters in life, but one should remember that we are all ultimately just human. there is no shame in taking a break for one’s health, and there is no shame in taking part in the society you’re forced to exist in. we are not preaching asceticism!

    self-hatred is what the enemy wants us to feel, as it causes demoralisation and helplessness and serves to turn structural pressures into a verdict on one’s own character. instead, direct your anger appropriately: it is not you who caused the world’s problems, but the bourgeoisie.

    lastly, i cannot emphasise enough that criticism isn’t the same as self-hatred. you can recognise mistakes and work to change without condemning your whole self.