• 40 Posts
  • 1.68K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 27th, 2023

help-circle












  • “My name is Avrietzur Detkowsky. I am the Summoned Hero, brought from Earth to Elgor 69. I do not wish to water you.”

    “Master, I do not understand. I am plant. I am to be watered.”

    “I cannot explain, but it goes against my Earth customs to water plant.”

    “But Master, surely we will be less conspicuous in our journey together if you water me, as I am plant.”

    “Oh, I wish I could explain the tortures of my soul, as I struggle to maintain morality in the face of temptation. But no one on Elgor understands, least of all my traveling companion, plant.”

    “Master, please, I am plant. I am potted. The runes on my ceramic pot clearly spell out that I am plant and I belong to Master.”

    [much later]

    “Oh no. Plant, my faithful companion, has fallen off a cliff and died.”



  • Skimming that script in much the same mood as deciding to watch Battlefield Earth, and the impression I get in addition to the points you make is just how joyless it is. I mean, I have an AO3 account. I grew up with some pulp in my literary diet. Sometimes you want to indulge in a genre convention just because, well, dammit, swordfights! Secret passages! Ah, Watson, terribly sorry to rouse you at an hour that God has possibly forsaken, but the game’s afoot! I can think of more than one adept fic writer who has gone, “Yep! This is the chapter wherein there is only one bed, ha ha!”

    Yud provides neither the pleasures of interrogating genre conventions nor those of wallowing in them. Joyless. The storytelling equivalent of the piss filter on Ghibli-ripoff slop.