Refusing to reduce complex reality into slogans and clichés since 19XX

  • 40 Posts
  • 1.08K Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 5th, 2026

help-circle









  • I’m tempted to conclude that actually paying for the service is the key factor here, but I’m not sure. It’s a highly self-selected userbase after all - people who joined the platform specifically to have these kinds of tough conversations.

    Perhaps it could work on a free platform as well. I guess the major difference is that getting banned comes with a real monetary cost and you can’t just create a new account in two minutes and go back to being obnoxious.

    It also incentivizes the admin team to keep the place in a state where people are willing to keep paying. In this case it’s the userbase they need to please - not the advertisers.



  • I joined a subscription-based social media platform recently that’s focused on intellectually honest and good faith discussion about pretty much anything. I never thought a bunch of strangers could act that civilly toward each other online. The contrast to other platforms like Lemmy cannot be overstated. No outrage, no grandstanding, no smug and dismissive responses, and no insults whatsoever. There’s plenty of disagreement there, but it’s all handled the way you’d expect adults to behave.

    Don’t know whether it’ll stay that way, but I’ll enjoy it while it lasts.






  • It’s a bit incoherent to criticize me for both not revealing the platform and advertising it in the same sentence.

    That is 100% engagement bait. That user will not change their mind, none ever do.

    Maybe, but it’s interesting to see them engaging with the immense pushback they’re getting. They might not change their mind, but it definitely gives me insight into what’s actually going on in the mind of a person like that. Nine times out of ten a post like that immediately devolves into personal attacks and name-calling, and no sane person wants to take part in that. I find this vastly more productive.






  • And I don’t mean expressing distaste for something when it’s relevant to the discussion.

    I don’t personally find that post complainy in the way I was talking about. It’s frustrating and kind of funny. I don’t sense any negative vibe there at all.

    The kind of complaining I’m talking about is the exhausting kind to be around. Even there I express my frustration but also say I have a solution for the problem.

    Pointing out everything wrong with the world without offering anything even remotely like a sustainable, realistic alternative is incredibly unproductive

    Ofcourse I too complain sometimes. I just try not to but I’m not perfect.