• 0 Posts
  • 7 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: July 26th, 2026

help-circle
  • I understand that during the most violent periods of the revolution it may be the only option for dealing with counter-revolutionaries. However once a stable sociaist state has been established with a prison system then there is no longer any material justification for it. All arguments for capital punishment under these conditions amount to an emotional desire to see someone bad punished. Functionally speaking capital punishment and life imprisonment work the exact same way, by removing a person who’s potential for recidivism is so dangerous to the population they must be removed permanently. The only difference is that life imprisonment can be corrected if there is a mistake (Which the state will inevitably make, to believe otherwise is idealism) capital punishment can’t. Ask yourself is the death of an innocent person worth your personal satisfaction at seeing someone who deserves to die be killed rather than simply imprisoned for life? For me the answer is obviously no. If yes then would you be ok if that innocent person was you or your family member? It’s understandable to want to see evil people punished as harshly as possible. I do too. But it’s an emotional desire. It’s not materialist and materially speaking if the option of life imprisonment exists then capital punishment is unjustifiable due to it’s irrevocable nature with regard to the inevitable mistakes of the state.