America is too big for planes, too. If your transportation solution is flying, now everyone has to get around via endless highways or big, complicated regional airports, and you can only have so many of those. There’s a reason why rural areas in North America have completely different politics from urban areas, and why so much of it is driven by a sense of isolation and abandonment. Trains promise to help here because they are able to stop in small places that will never, ever have practical airports.

A good rail network provides a reliable, consistent, repeatable, and straightforward three hour connection from Nowheresberg to the nearest city. Slow, but good enough to feel like they exist in the same planet. Unfortunately, that promise is subtle, and it plays out over decades, so the reward system we’ve created for ourselves is incapable of supporting it. And thus, we have Amtrak and confederate flags

https://cosocial.ca/@dylanmccall/113233671160717813

  • AA5B@lemmy.worldEnglish
    0·
    3 months ago

    Are you counting things like shopping, medical care, visiting friends and family, education , and events like concerts or sports as tourism?

    DO they need to have a reason? You can simply look at existing traffic to see where a train would offer better scale.

    • most sufficiently large cities have existing traffic to support rail in and out. Basically commuter rail
    • most sufficiently large city pairs less than 500 miles apart have existing traffic to support intercity rail. Amtrak.
    • the vast majority of transportation funding goes toward road and air, while rail has been undergfunded at least half a century
    • dejected_warp_core@lemmy.worldEnglish
      0·
      3 months ago

      Thanks for the deeper think on this. I’m out my depth by not living in such an area - I knew I wasn’t going to cover all the bases on my own.

      Are you counting things like shopping, medical care, visiting friends and family, education , and events like concerts or sports as tourism?

      So, no, but after reading this it makes a lot more sense. Thank you.