I wanted to remind people about this drama from the creator of HA, Frenck toward Nix maintainers packaging Home-Assistant in nixpkgs.
If he behaves in this immature, dictatorial way, it is not a stretch to think that he will eventually close his source code and/or cash in on the popularity of his open source software like the Pi Foundation and OpenAI did to differing degrees.
TLDR; Frenck is convinced that he has the right to unilaterally mandate how people package his free, open source software and, in my opinion, will most likely behave with similar lack of integrity/lack of transparency with regards to profiteering off of his work eventually. We should fork the project ASAP to protect it from the power-hungry Luddite in charge (that reminds me of Spez).
That immutable state considers the lock files of ALL the dependencies listed and needed to build the software. You don’t seem to understand the technology enough to weigh in.
It downloads them then compares them with the expected hashes. If they don’t match, it literally won’t build.
Ah. So there are even more people whose fault is that they do not understand…
;-)
I probably don’t know enough about the project, but how can it know what requirements plugins installed at a later time have?
Python generates hashed lock files of every dependency it builds. It simply queries that and matches that against its own builds. If they’re not using lock files and such, there are MUCH bigger problems in that project. ;)
Plugin systems don’t rely on lock files, they’re not part of the build at all.
Wow. I stand corrected. That’s actually scary. Has anyone mentioned a solution to this glaring issue? It’s fairly trivial to do that by the way. All that needs to happen is to hash the output of each plugin and the version numbers and compatibility issues would be easier to understand and reproducible.
I’m guessing that those plugins have their own nix derivations that are handled in a more reliable manner. No wonder the dude has extra technical debt popping up! He hasn’t even thought to atomically declare his dependencies.
From what I gather here you have a particular flavor of a distribution that does not work with a foss piece of software. This is not uncommon.
Developers have finite time and energy to put into the development of their platform and likely spend that time supporting their existing user base. Just because you took the time to learn esperanto and think it is a superior language does not mean everyone else must cater to your whims.
Based on your statements you seem to “understand” nix… Instead of demanding they cater to your needs: Perhaps you should undertake the burden of forking, modifying the code, and supporting the vast ecosystem of addons then. Surely it would be a trivial matter.
That’s the thing that NONE of you get. We literally don’t need anything nor are we asking anything of Frenck. We packaged Home-Assistant and there it sits in nixpkgs without ANY involvement from Frenck.
and that’s what YOU don’t understand:
you take his software and put it on your platform, without supporting it propperly…
don’t package it, if you are not willing to support it. simple as that…