Brother do you need gum? I have plenty to share.
Yes.
IDK much about communism, but the one thing I do know is that you don’t want literal pigs in your revolution.
The central point of Animal Farm is that workers are stupid and incapable of understanding their own conditions, and thus will endlessly be taken advantage of by charismatic leaders. It’s a deeply aristocratic take that erases the agency of the working classes. Orwell was also a snitch, keeping lists of Jews and communists to report to the British feds.
Having worked in a range of professions over decades, a lot of it “customer facing”, I can wholeheartedly say with full conviction that a lot of people -worker or otherwise- are as thick as a bucket of pigshit, and that’s not being entirely fair on the pigshit.
I’m not trying to make any kind of political statement here, merely pointing out that a statistically significant portion of people are comically stupid.
People are generally able to understand their own interests, and are capable of learning and growing.
If that were true, Nigel Farage wouldn’t be half as popular as he is.
Or, Nigel Farage’s support base has a specific class character that does benefit.
The only thing they have in common is that they’re easy to exploit.
We’re talking about fishermen who think “Reform will fix what the EU did to our fisheries”, for example. There is no explanation for that other than sheer stupidity.
People are largely shaped by their material conditions, they don’t necessarily have ideas beamed into their heads nor are they exceptionally out of the norm on average.
IDK much about communism, but what I do know I learned from an anticommunist propagandist fiction writer.
Another normal day.
You can’t be referring to Orwell here, can you?
Who else would they be referring to? The central point of Animal Farm is that workers are stupid and incapable of understanding their own conditions, and thus will endlessly be taken advantage of by charismatic leaders. It’s a deeply aristocratic take that erases the agency of the working classes. Orwell was also a snitch, keeping lists of Jews and communists to report to the British feds. Fuck Orwell. That’s all without getting into the allegations that he was a sex abuser when he was young as well.
Yeah, lemmy.ml checks out. The point of animal farm was specifically to show how Stalin betrayed the Revolution for his own gains. You got Trotsky as snowball, Stalin as Napoleon and Lenin as Old mayor.
It’s about how people have to be careful who to give too much power, and how easily the public can be deceived. In the end it shows the pigs walking upright and partying with the humans, who were an allegory for the capitalists. Because the ruling class wasn’t abolished, it was merely replaced by party officials
Yep, you nailed the intention of Orwell, who was an awful person to begin with. He was, after all, a fierce anti-communist and snitch. I’m aware of the allegorical ties to Stalin, Trotsky, and Old Major being a mix of Marx and Lenin, as are most people. However, reading the book, you can clearly see that everything rests on a central thesis:
The working class, specifically the Russian working class, is mind-bogglingly stupid, helpless, and cannot think for themselves to save their own lives, and are therefore destined to be taken advantage of.
This isn’t a stretch in any capacity. Orwell had a very aristocratic attitude towards the working class, and considered himself better than them (see the linked article below). Here’s how he describes workers in Animal Farm, taken from A Critical Read of Animal Farm:
Orwell begins his story with Old Major, a pig metaphor for Karl Marx, who introduces the principles of Animalism — Marxism. With the exception of the other pigs, none of the animals can really grasp the depth of his theory, but they like what they hear anyway. The stage is set, and Orwell begins introducing the rest of the cast. Boxer and Clover are the first representatives of the working class that the reader learns about:
Clover was a stout motherly mare approaching middle life, who never quite got her figure back after her fourth foal. Boxer was an enormous beast, nearly eighteen hands high, and as strong as any two ordinary horses put together. A white stripe down his nose gave him a somewhat stupid appearance, and in fact he was not of first-rate intelligence, but he was universally respected for his steadiness of character and tremendous powers of work.
Boxer is the personification of The Worker — a metaphor for the Stakhanovite movement in the USSR. [4] Orwell then goes back to Old Major and the preparation for the upcoming revolution, caricaturing Marxism as a simple doctrine where animals simply label humans as a great enemy, and insist that all life will immediately improve as soon as the humans — the bourgeois — disappear. This is what Orwell says about this process:
Major’s speech had given to the more intelligent animals on the farm a completely new outlook on life. They didn’t know when the Rebellion predicted by Major would take place, they had no reason for thinking that it would be within their own lifetime, but they saw clearly that it was their duty to prepare for it. The work of teaching and organizing the others fell naturally upon the pigs, who were generally recognized as being the cleverest of the animals.
The pigs, the revolutionaries, are said to be the cleverest. But what about the working class?
Some of the animals talked of the duty of loyalty to Mr. Jones, whom they referred to as “Master,” or made elementary remarks such as “Mr. Jones feeds us. If he were gone, we should starve to death.” Others asked such questions as “Why should we care what happens after we are dead?” or “If this Rebellion is to happen anyway, what difference does it make whether we work for it or not?”, and the pigs had great difficulty in making them see that this was contrary to the spirit of Animalism. The stupidest questions of all were asked by Mollie the white mare.
The animals being described as “stupid” or otherwise made to seem dumb or incapable is a running theme throughout the novel. Orwell continues:
Their most faithful disciples were the two cart-horses, Boxer and Clover. These two had great difficulty in thinking anything out for themselves, but having once accepted the pigs as their teachers, they absorbed everything that they were told, and passed it on to the other animals by simple arguments. They were unfailing in their attendance at the secret meetings in the barn, and led the singing of “Beasts of England,” with which the meetings always ended.
Here “Beasts of England” is a metaphor for “The Internationale.”
Boxer was the admiration of everybody. He had been a hard worker even in Jones’ time, but now he seemed more like three horses than one; there were days when the entire work of the farm seemed to rest on his mighty shoulders. From morning to night, he was pushing and pulling, always at the spot where the work was hardest. He had made an arrangement with one of the cockerels to call him in the morning half an hour earlier than anyone else, and would put in some volunteer labor at whatever seemed to be most needed, before the regular day’s work began. His answer to every problem, every setback was “I will work harder!” — which he had adopted as his personal motto.
Orwell describes Boxer as a hard worker — excited for working, someone who believes in the revolutionary project, and also always as dumb. Boxer as subject is pure, he truly and wholeheartedly believes in the revolution and in Animalism, and this makes him gullible.
Time passes, Old Major dies, and the revolution goes on without him. We are treated to assemblies organized by Snowball and Napoleon — Trotsky and Stalin — in its aftermath:
Here the work of coming week was planned out and resolutions were put forward and debated. It was always the pigs who put forward the resolutions. The other animals understood how to vote, but could never think of any resolutions of their own.
Check this out: it’s not the case that the other animals are being manipulated. There’s no institution that manufactures consent here. Animal Farm is not Nineteen Eighty-Four, which portrays ideological control in complex terms, including some ideas I appreciate, like the manipulation of the past as a mechanism of domination. In Animal Farm the process is straightforward: the animals are fooled because they are dumb; there’s no complex scheme here. You might argue “Jones, it’s not a complex book, the narrative is simplified!” Listen, I understand that the book is simple by nature, that everything is direct for a reason, but you notice this in turn: when it comes to the betrayal of the revolution, the subversion of the revolution, there’s no challenge for the pigs. Do you get it? It’s easy for the pigs, because the working class is stupid.
The entire essay is fantastic, written by a Brazilian communist and politician, Jones Manoel. And yes, I obviously have issues with how Orwell depicts Marxism, because I myself am a Marxist-Leninist. His works were promoted by the CIA to discredit communism and socialism in the eyes of the working class, it’s why everybody knows about 1984 and Animal Farm. Hell, Isaac Asimov absolutely hated 1984 for being a horrendous understanding of politics, so it’s not like it’s only Marxists that gave an issue with Orwell’s work
I recommend you reject Orwell’s aristocratic “socialism” and believe in the abilities of the working class. We already run the world, we should own it, too.
Why not? Training some pigs to advance against the police in protests would be awesome
ALL HAIL SNOWBALL
Fuck lenin
Why?
He was a terrible person and a terrible leader is why. I am a anarcho/council communist so not apologizing for any sort of capitalism here but the way Lenin ran things was shit! They were so focused in not being like the bourgeoise they replaced that it ran so inefficient with 10 different stupid coincils and they were not pro worker either except for a couple of branches who Lenin and his guys actively hindered. Stalin gets flack because of how terrible he ran things but as terrible as he was he inherited that system from lenin
What specifically was bad about the Soviet system, and what was bad about Lenin as a leader? The Soviet system was very efficient, especially in the first several decades before World War II. Workers saw enormous benefits, like democratization of society and the workplace, free education and healthcare, and rents at or below 10% of monthly incomes, with 40 hour work weeks. Women joined the government and gained the ability to no-fault divorce their husbands. Workers gained a ton from socialism.
So what do you have to say about them toying with militarization of labor?
What do you mean specifically?
IDK, maybe killing shitloads of people by shipping them off to gulags?
That didn’t happen, though. The overwhelming majority of deaths in the GULAG system were from starvation in the 1940s, due to the Nazis invading Ukraine to starve out the Soviet people. Further, the GULAG administration began after Lenin, and was disbanded in 1956. Below is the mortality rate data from Wikipedia:
Year Deaths Mortality rate %

A correct analysis of the Soviet Union is necessary, because it was the first socialist state. We need to be critical, but base our critique on fact, not fiction. There’s plenty that went wrong, but there’s also plenty that went very, very well. We can learn from both.
SNOWBALL was a TRAITOR secretly working with farmer jones. NAPOLEON is the only pig that can lead this GLORIOUS REVOLUTION.
FOUR LEGS GOOD, TWO LEGS BETTER





