Regardless of how bad the current US administration is, Americanophiles - like the Polish girl from the linked clip, who wished well to the US on the occasion of the last 4th of July - still end up looking more reasonable than Americanophobes, realizing that the current crop of US career politicians is not representative of the broader American culture and tradition.
Is this a country or a cult?
Fuck nationalism. Workers of the world unite!
Good unpopular opinion.
Upvoted for having an actual unpopular (and uneducated) opinion.
Posts in unpopular opinions comm… Post is about something so popular that it nets negative votes…
Get out of here with your popular opinion! /s
Who the fuck cares about tradition and culture… it’s all just lifted from other cultures anyway. To me, knowing that enough people voted for a KNOWN CHILD-RAPIST and 37-time CONVICTED FELON, is enough to never trust Muricans, ever.
I think the idea is not to be on team nationhood, but instead be with team humanity.
They have culture and tradition?
Did i miss something like how America invented the croissant, french fries or the hamburger?
Yes you did miss something. America invented French fries and hamburgers in the sense that we kinda created fast food… yk… like the fast food that is all over the world.
Or maybe all of television… did you forget about Hollywood?
Or the most popular music ever? Blues? Rap? Country? Rock? Grunge? Pop?
I could go on and on and on. You’re an idiot.
They dug up a fast food restaurant in Pompeii. That’s hardly in the States?! And like 1400 years before discovering the New World?
Movie theaters were popularized in London and Paris in and the cathode ray tube was invented by two Germans.
Punk, rock etc I think was also heavily influenced by the Brits. I mean one of the most influential rock bands was from Liverpool (UK). But indeed lots of music is a cultural achievement which originated in the USA. Wouldn’t make me feel patriotic, though, since it happened by kidnapping lots of people from another continent and they brought the music.
At least get your facts right if you decide to insult other people.
No my facts are right, you decided to just add a little bit of nuance that skims over everything I said.
Yes maybe pompeii had fast food, that’s completely ignoring the fact that America still invented it in the modern sense and popularized it.
Never said movie and media didn’t originate in the us. Hollywood created the most famous and watched movies however, so still, that’s culture.
Ahh yes because African American culture somehow doesn’t matter because they were enslaved 🤔 African American culture is the way it is because they were enslaved, that doesn’t mean their culture is bad because of that.
Punk and rock yes were influenced by the Brits, but rock originated in the states from African Americans.
I can go on and on about American culture, you guys simply ignore and don’t realize what American culture really is and represents. Maybe you should pull your head out of your ass and do a little research yourself.
Hehe, just go to any random place abroad and see if they accept American fast food as culture. It’s not even a mainstream thing… We’ll eat Döner Kebap here and lots of Pizza. None of that is American in any way or form. The occasional MacDonald’s we keep around is for the 5 people without taste buds, and if it’s 3am and all the other places are closed for cleaning. Our neigbours eat Bamischijf, the Brits eat fish and chips… Literally no one eats what the US Americans portray as food. And even they’ll prefer burritos if available.
Yes. People certainly added to movie and music. It’s just the more cultured someone is, the more distance they get between themselves and something like Hollywood productions and country music because what the USA is definitely good at is make things big and commercialize them. I just don’t think there’s a lot of unique American-ness in something like music. It was a global effort, the spirit and temper comes from abroad… And yes, some of the influential exchange happened on US soil.
But that wasn’t what you were saying. You said “America invented”… And they clearly didn’t invent any of what we’re talking about.
Ok you just kinda ignore what I say by stating you don’t partake and that in whatever shitty euro country your in doesn’t either. So you should do a little more research on American culture, seeing as your not from here, it’s pretty evident your not qualified to have an opinion on it. I mean if you want I can name about 100 things America invented, popularized, or just list American culture.
Lol. I mean if I’m not allowed to talk about the US because I don’t live there… You probably also don’t get to use the word “culture” because you’re likely from there and have no clue what culture is?!
I mean if you want I can name about 100 things […]
Sure go ahead. But make it like 5. And proper things which really got invented there and they didn’t just add two things on top and relabeled it as American.
Ok you just kinda ignore what I say by stating […]
What are you even talking about? I reply to each point you raise?!? I mean I can feel you’re not happy with the answers, how nobody else sees it this way… But that doesn’t make what I say less true?!
- Blue jeans - invented by Jacob Davis and Levi Strauss in Sanfran
- Basketball and baseball
- Rodeo and Cowboys (although some was inherited by Spain/ Spanish during the first cattle drives in Mexico, cowboys and rodeo are its own distinct culture within America)
- Sitcoms, reality tv, Hollywood
- Indians, Cajun, etc
- High school culture (homecoming, prom, Friday night lights)
American culture is a mix of many cultures, although I do not believe America is or should be a melting pot, what is deemed American culture is a homogenous mix of many cultures. In places like Texas you’ll get Tex-mex - a distinct food that blends Texas cuisine with Spanish cuisine. Just because it’s a mix of cultures into 1, doesn’t mean that it’s not American. That’s the thing, you’re correct in that there isn’t a monoculture in America, but everybody in America shares part of their culture which results in an American culture.
For example, living in your euro dump I’m sure you haven’t been exposed to as much Spanish cuisines, or Cajun food, etc etc. while in America almost everyone has been to a Spanish restaurant, it may not be an individuals culture, but they still partake in it.
This isn’t worded quite how I wish, but you should get the idea.
do you know the difference between yogurt and the united states?
spoiler
if you leave the yogurt alone for 250 years it develops a culture
I’ll say this, at least 1/3 of US adults seem like good people. As for the rest… well idk but the recent election restore my faith in America… sort of
I can’t say the same about where my parent’s came from (People’s Republic of China), it’s much more toxic of a society IMO. Perhaps its not the individuals, but its a culture issue. First thing that comes to mind is that depression is never recognized and therefore everything if your fault.
China’s Paramount Leader Xi Jinping, literally said “welfare makes people lazy”. Straight out of the far-right talking point. CCP basically just has communist aesthetics but has a lot of overlap with MAGA. All the people in China who cannot find a job is just labled “lazy”, totally not the government’s fault. 🙄
Also society have a lot of money worship, and not just as a pragmatic means to better life, but like theres a lot harsher “if you’re poor, you’re worthless”.
Also, toxic masculinity, and misogyny still are huge issues.
Don’t get me started on the “marriage market”, marriages are loveless… Society there is so much more messed up than the US.
USA > PRC is all I can say. I’m not gonna deny that there’s other countries that have people living happier lives.
honestly, the elections restored some of my faith in the yanks as well, but it’s far from complete.
the main thing it showed imo is that the “it’s the economy, stupid” line was genuine. which is, plainly speaking, idiotic. the yanks had one of the best economies on the planet in the biden years – yeah, things sucked, because we literally just had a global pandemic, but they were climbing out of it way better than anyone else. but no, that’s not good enough for these morons who believe they live in the greatest country that ever country’d, they think anything bad that happens to them must be due to excessive incompetence, because otherwise yankistan is somehow immune to trouble.
speaking of the median american here, ofc. there are staunch republicans of course that voted for project 2025 willingly, and there are sane democrats too. but the apolitical middle (not “apolitical” as in poorly disguised republican, like most people who use that word for themselves, but actually apolitical in that they don’t care enough about their own future to get involved) is actually, genuinely, utterly stupid and simplistic.
it’s somehow strangely a relief that it’s “just” this, that to most people, “it’s the economy, stupid” wasn’t a partisan lie, but a genuine, if grossly uninformed perspective. but internationally, it only means we’re mostly dealing with benevolent idiots, not malevolent grifters, the latter group just managed to abuse the former to get in power for a while.
there’s no guarantee there won’t be a next maga movement, but at least we now know that the majority of yanks who either voted for it or refused to stop it didn’t do so because they wanted all the nazi trash that was advertised with it, they were just too stupid to understand that it wouldn’t make them rich. which is slightly less bad than if they were actually all nazis.
Omg lemme tell you about my older brother. He’s a racist piece of shit. Like he literally called black people “cockcoaches that repopulate too quickly”
He only votes (or at least seems to proclaim to vote) dems cuz he isn’t white, cuz he said trump was racist to Asians… oh you’d think? “Pot calling kettle black” LMFAO
So we do have obvious propaganda bots on lemmy.
Check .ml. That’s where they all come from.
What exactly are US lovers excited about? What part of the US is paving the way for our future. What is there to like about the US, seriously. Unless you are psychotic and wealthy I don’t see the allure.
Also, how does this mesh with the natural negative bias of US society. I think any rational person paying attention can name a lot more wrong with the US than right regardless of politics.
the current crop of US career politicians is not representative of the broader American culture and tradition.
The current presidential administration is very representative of many millions of Americans. Not most Americans, that’s true, but many.
That said, I agree that the current administration is a fairly significant deviation from what had been the political norm for all of my life, but that norm wasn’t all that great, either, in my opinion.
Frankly, I don’t love broader American culture, if such a thing even exists anymore. Much has been said and written about the decline of American monoculture. It’s likely the culture of MAGA voters, however that might be defined, is just one of several distinct cultures that the American monoculture has fractured into, and I don’t think it’s going anywhere.
in Reddit terms,if you’re comparing ShitAmericansSay, you should compare that with AmericaBad. the person in the video just seems like somebody with lots of love and compassion. your definition of “Americanophiles” does not relate to political opinions at all
I love americanos! Been making them ever since James Hoffmann put out this video!
Based on the few comments here so far this is definitely unpopular.
I do think that negativity is more poorly received then positivity. Who likes someone who’s always shitting on others?
No, they don’t. It shows that they are completely out of touch with reality.
Why anyone would think that nazi fans seem “more stable” than those pointing out reality in a somber way? Sounds like a YOU problem.





