I alwayse check this before downloading apps because i dont want apps to spy on me. And what i noticed in practise is that usualy payd apps offten dont collect any data and even if they do its less data than free apps.
So obviusly they collect that data to sell it and to make money that way. And if you think only big companies for advertising buy that data you are wrong.
Gowermants, secret organizacions and milioners who want to control your life is bying that data the most.
That’s why I have almost no social media. but I had to choose between apple and google so right now only google has all my personal information, habits, location, interests etc…
This section is almost worthless. It’s wholly reliant on the app developer self-reporting accurately, and honestly. We know how effective self-regulation is…
Just assume ALL apps are data harvesting, and take measures to block or sabotage that.
Other Data
Yeah
It depends. If I’m looking for a new app that does task X, I look at my options and compare them against eachother using that box.
All the time, especially since we know already…
Heck ya I do, that’s why I don’t have an account. And I barely use that app…
Yes i do pay attention to it and normally wont download ones that have data collection on apps that have no need for that.
Apple requires that binaries are submitted to them prior to be ing placed on the app store. This where the app gets analyzed to see if it matches their policies etc…. Im sure there are flaws in this system but i generally trust it since its in apples favor to have this info be correct.
I wish as a user I could deny app’s permissions. Normally it’s just something like below with no option to break certain functionality for privacy.
This app will …
[Install] [Cancel]
I don’t know the state of it these days, but there was a shim layer for android called Magisk that had a plugin that would allow you to spoof permissions to apps. So the app thinks it has access to your location and contacts, but what they actually have is a random GPS coord and an empty list.
I want this to be how permissions control works, but apple and google have no incentive to give it to us.
It works like this on newer Android versions. A specific permission is usually asked if a certain fearure uses it.
That’s the idea anyway. In practice, half the apps ask for it on first setup so (tech-illiterate) people are expecting the prompt and know to click yes next finish
It’s still the developer’s choice when the prompt is shown, just that it moved from AndroidManifest.xml to executable code so now they have the option to not ask until it’s actually needed and handle denies gracefully (in practice, half the apps just close if not every useless thing is granted)
I also seem to remember it’s a policy of Google’s that permission mustn’t be asked until required, but if I remember this right, I’m either not using enough of their store-vetted adware or they’re not checking this properly
I pay attention to everything, and refuse to install any apps. I block 90% of the data from apps I have installed, only allowing a couple to access certain things (banking for example). The first thing I do with any android phone is go through and disable all of the bloat from google, disable chrome and turn off most of the settings. Install a decent browser and plugins to block tracking, ads and so forth. I don’t install social media apps, in fact I’m not on any corporate owned social media, I use signal/telegram for messaging… I deleted old SM accounts starting in 2012 with facebook and ending with twitter in 2018. I use email services like a duck.com address or proton mail for online signups where required, along with alias spam accounts for certain things that can easily be deleted and stop spam.
From next year, I will only be buying phones that can be jailbroken and an alt OS installed.
I go even further with my home PC’s to protect my privacy… I can’t stop it all, but I can render what they do collect as worthless as possible.
You can use graphine os i think its the best. Do you know what is open source software?
Instagramies are addicted to the platform. I have seen my sister and my bro-in-law, comparing their likes, etc. For context, they get likes in low double digits. It’s despicable.
I do, but I sometimes wonder why I bother. In the Play store, the information is pretty frequently inaccurate. It used to be that absolutely everything was asking for every permission and collecting every form of data under the sun. These days I far more frequently see the claim that “this app doesn’t collect any data” only to discover that the app will have a website with a detailed privacy policy (for the app, not the site) outlining all the data they’re collecting that they theoretically aren’t collecting. I really don’t understand how that’s allowable but it surprised me.
Typically these days I try my best only to use things I can find on fdroid. Sounds like that’s about to no longer be an option next year though.
I use iphone for now but i plan to discard it and switch to graphine os or ubuntu touch. So i will be over with those spying things. Am enough of them.
Sure, Graphene OS tries it’s best to limit Apps, but if you don’t trust an App, you just shouldn’t run it, no matter the OS.
As long as sideloading is a thing, I don’t use the Google app store. And I don’t install malware like Instagram - not that it’s very likely to work on my deGoogled Android cellphone.
Of course, now that fucking Google has declared war on deGoogled ROMs, what I’m saying here is pretty much a dead-end. But as of today, it’s still an option.
Fuck Google.
Also, in case it bore repeating: fuck Google.
And finally, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention that Google can go fuck itself.
The devs behind GrapheneOS are aiming to eventually release phones with native support, which I imagine will involve shifting away from AOSP (especially since the endgame is definitely killing AOSP despite what the cunts at Google claim).
Hoping I can make that jump before the Trump regime makes it illegal for any tech company to not be easily exploitable by his gestapo
To answer to your question, no, most people don’t. And at any case, showing a screen like that is far too late in the process. If the user has decided to install Instagram, then showing them a screen like this won’t do a thing. Their mind is already made. If we want online privacy to really matter, then the question of online privacy needs to be solved higher up in political policy level in form of regulations as well as lower level in form of awareness and education. It can’t be left to be done in app installation screen by individual end-users.
Good on you for being privacy conscious though.
That isn’t the app installation screen. It’s the store page. Where else would you show it? Telepathically to the user as soon as they think of the app?
Or maybe we shouldn’t be allowing data collection and surveillance in the first place.
The website you use right now literally wouldn’t function without “data collection”.
Tell me, what data does Beehaw sell to the brokers?
Nobody said anything about selling data. You said data collection. And the fediverse is literally entirely public, so beehaw doesn’t have to do anything for your activity here to be tracked across numerous locations.
Yeah bud, very topical
Well i think education is the cay because if people have freedom to chose than we dont strictly need any regulations about that, exscept those that say you have to mention what will you do with data in agreement papers.
There is so much good open source software today that people should realy be more aware about what open source actualy means and why privacy is so important…
And about this screen, whenever i see interesting game on app store i check this page and refuse to install it if it looks like this.
And when i search for an app i refuse to install app like this and search further until i find app for same purpose but without data colection.
Thats why i more like to see small price on app than to see it free. Because its more likly payed app will have no data colected banner. :)
And i think thats a win win situacion both for developers and us.
