There’s another option though. Any paint store/ department sells rolls of plain brown paper for use as a dropcloth. That’s what I use instead of cardboard. It’s not particularly expensive, and it’s as easy to roll out as landscaping fabric.

There’s some really good research and info on this site: https://www.anourishingharvest.com/

When it comes to chemical pollutants and health I think it’s the concentrations that are more relevant than the scale. Grams of toxins spread over a vegetable garden could easily be worse than tonnes of toxins spread over a big farm.

It’s laborious to measure the amount of known toxins in your soil and even more laborious to measure the health impacts of them, so I just stick to using things that I know the soil can process naturally. Apart from not wanting to poison myself I also don’t want to poison future generations or create a dystopian problem for them to have to fix.

To be honest though, in my experience mulching is a bit overrated and ends up being pretty much the same amount of work/hassle as doing a bit of a digging here and there. Also, digging, weeding and tidying help you to get to know the life of your garden and become more intimate with it, with I think is totally solarpunk :)

It only prevents it when it’s there.

Thr cardboard/newspaper prevents germination of new weeds, and blocks off light from old weeds, generally killing them.

I used this to reclaim a wild patch into a garden bed with cardboard and pine needles as mulch. Took a few months, but it even killed some blackbeery brambles. They came the fuck back of course, but it was enough to get the patch going right.

Dont use colorful or waxed cardboard, and remove all tape. Its annoying, but better than picking it out of the garden later.

It doesn’t, but keep in mind that most weeds grow from seeds or roots in the immediate vicinity of where they end up. Even if you wipe out all of the above-ground weeds, there are typically thousands of dormant seeds and root fragments that will rapidly repopulate the area in response to the soil disturbance and lack of competition after this removal.

Proper sheet mulching prevents these roots and seeds from immediately repopulating the space. You’ll still have weeds invading from border areas and the occasional long-term dispersal but these will be much smaller in numbers and more easily handled by other methods. If the latent weed population in a larger space can be eliminated then the amount of weeding needed can be very low.

Also, very few weed seeds can establish in more typical mulch material like straw or wood chips. Thick layers of organic material require a large energy reserve to push through, usually provided by an existing root system. So once the process is completed, you can prevent recolonization with more ordinary mulching methods, though you’ll still have to fight at the borders if large weed populations exist there.